Justice in Africa Archives - Pan-African Catholic Theology and Pastoral Network

Pope Leo’s African Moment: A Prophetic Political Theology— A Test for African Bishops and Theologians, Part II

Pope Leo’s African moment is an epiphany, revealing to the Church and the world the kind of Pope God has given us. We are at the early stages of a papacy rooted in our ancient tradition and bold in proclaiming the truth of the faith with humility and joy. It is a papacy marked by deep respect for the many pathways and the diversity of cultures, races, nations, and religions that flow into the vast ocean of God’s mission, within which the Catholic Church carries on her fragile yet sacred vocation. What stands out most clearly in Pope Leo’s mission to Africa, amid today’s complex socio-political and ideological divisions, is his enunciation of a prophetic political theology. In this, he not only retrieves Catholic Social Teaching but applies it with remarkable boldness to the moral and spiritual crisis of our confused world, addressing national and global politics, the dignity and rights of all peoples, the ethics of war and peace, love of neighbor especially the poor and suffering, and offering a critique of the sinful structures of domination, corruption, and manipulation in defense of the common good. What is Pope Leo’s Prophetic Political Theology? This prophetic political theology, in Leo’s emerging usage, is not partisan theory, clerical statecraft, or papal overreach, as some whose consciences have been whipped by the prophetic sting from the mouth of the Pope might claim. Rather, it is a Gospel grounded reading of political life that makes an ethical judgment of the social order according to how far it is ordered to peace, justice, social friendship, truth, human dignity, the participation of all citizens, and the common good, while calling rulers, citizens, and institutions to conversion so that the reign of God may emerge in history. “The heart of this prophetic political theology is articulated through a closer reading of Pope Leo’s speeches and in-flight interviews during his ongoing pilgrimage of peace to Africa. ” — Stan Chu Ilo This prophetic political theology could be understood, I argue, through a set of interrelated questions about the right ordering of society in light of the Gospel, namely: How is authority and power exercised as a form of service, ordered to the common good and the flourishing of all, especially the poor and most vulnerable? How are structures of governance shaped to foster certain outcomes: participation, co-responsibility, and the dignity of every person in a spirit of communion akin to the African ubuntu? How are the diverse identities, interests, and aspirations of people discerned, reconciled, and integrated within a social order that respects difference while nurturing unity, solidarity, and social friendship? By what means are collaboration, coordination, and mutual accountability cultivated among persons, communities, and institutions, so that subsidiarity and solidarity work together in advancing the common good, shared purposes, and promoting human and cosmic flourishing? And how are questions of justice, equity, and fairness discerned in light of the dignity of the human person and the demands of the Gospel, so that social, economic, and political arrangements are rightly ordered, relationships are restored, and all people participate through their assets to building a society of abundant life for all where no one is excluded from the goods of creation? All these questions, I believe, can be understood within what I see as the Church’s preference for institutionalism as a political theory. Here, to borrow an idea from Lowndes, Marsh, and Stoker in Theory and Methods in Political Science, there is a focus on the “rules, norms, and values” that govern politics and governance, and on the institutions that regulate and promote the common life and the good of order. These norms are derived from natural law, divine positive law, the Gospel message, and the living Tradition and Magisterial teaching of the Church, discerned within history, human experience, and ecclesial life. They are universally applicable because they relate to the good of all human beings, whether they are Christians or not. However, in Pope Leo’s view, these values are not arbitrarily dictated, nor should the institutions that govern our common life locally or globally be imposed on the populace or the rest of the world by a few individuals or a few nations, and sustained by a tightly knit, narrow political class. “This is the problem in a country like Cameroon or Equatorial Guinea, where a thin top layer of the political class, or a cabal of patrons who has captured the state, as it were, turns statecraft into thievery, extraction, prebendalism, and extraversion, while using the state’s monopoly of violence to maintain tight control over a restive and disinherited masses who cry daily to God.” — Stan Chu Ilo This is also the challenge the world faces in America’s unilateralism or exceptionalism, where it uses its military or economic might to advance a narrow vision of history, spiced with a warped Christian eschatology that, sadly, has the ugly face of a new form of idolatry, having nothing to do with the reign of God, and the God of peace and love revealed to the world by our Lord Jesus Christ. Pope Leo is inviting the world and Christians to take away the robe of Christianity from right-wing white Christian nationalists, who wish to resurrect the ideals and projects of a defunct Christendom. “I think Pope Leo is inviting Christians to infuse their societies with Christian values rather than to dominate them through Christian politics or a Christian theocracy.” — Stan Chu Ilo From this perspective, it seems that Pope Leo invites the world to recognize that institutions of power should be continually renewed through reflective practices. This renewal should be informed by a social imagination that connects an understanding of people\’s daily joys and sorrows with the norms and ideals of good governance. These norms should arise from, resonate with, and address the social conditions to ensure that the social order is just, equitable, and promotes human security and the common good, which everyone should be able to access like a wellspring. How has Pope

Pope Leo’s African Moment: A Prophetic Political Theology— A Test for African Bishops and Theologians, Part II Read More »

Pope Leo’s African Moment: A Prophetic Political Theology— A Test for African Bishops and Theologians, Part I

The world has been quite fascinated by what is emerging as the prophetic political theology of Pope Leo. Forbes, for instance, calls Pope Leo’s proclamation of the social gospel “a masterclass in moral courage.” CNN’s Christopher Lamb writes that Pope Leo is “reclaiming Christian values from the Trump administration.” The Financial Times similarly observes that Leo’s early interventions suggest a return to a morally assertive papacy in global affairs, while The Economist interprets his voice as part of a renewed Catholic willingness to offer a moral critique of political and economic power. The New York Times has described Leo as reasserting the moral voice of the papacy in an age of political fragmentation, and The Guardian highlights his readiness to challenge power across ideological divides in the name of human dignity and justice. Even the BBC notes the distinctive character of his leadership: a pastoral voice that speaks with unusual directness into the political crises of our time. “These positive affirmations of the Pope’s message and courageous moral voice reveal that, despite its own weaknesses and limitations, the Catholic Church, represented by the papacy, remains the world’s most visible moral authority today.” — Stan Chu Ilo In the face of the moral and spiritual bankruptcy of many political leaders across the globe, and the crisis of history unfolding in the epidemic of war and violence in our world, there is a pressing need. As Pope Leo says, there is a need for someone to speak out against these evils. There must also be a convincing message of an alternative path to a peaceful world, one that spreads love, prosperity, and happiness rather than hate, violence, and suffering among the majority of God’s people. “Pope Leo’s message offers an alternative path through what I call his prophetic political theology, which transcends his person. He speaks from within a deep and living tradition, with both Augustinian and Gospel roots, as articulated in Catholic Social Teaching.” — Stan Chu Ilo This tradition has consistently upheld the ordering of society toward the promotion of the common good, understood not merely as social stability or the absence of war, but as a moral and spiritual horizon oriented toward justice, the good life, and the flourishing of all. In this vision, the dignity, rights, and vocation of every person are safeguarded and advanced, so that society may foster sustainable and integral human development, and the ordination of all things toward the fulfillment of history in acts of love and solidarity. As I argue in my book on Pope Leo, Dilexi Te: A Church Formed by Love, he is quietly reinventing Catholic social teaching to meet the fragmented post-liberal world of today, where the erstwhile global institutions designed after World War II are exhausted and fraying under the weight of the inner contradictions of modernity’s lies about a convergent trajectory of history. “In Pope Leo’s speeches in Africa, we see a direct and unambiguous retrieval and application of Catholic Social Teaching to concrete historical realities, and, more importantly, the courageous naming of the actors whose invisible hands weave the tangled yarn of structural violence, spinning, knotting, and tightening the threads of injustice into rough fabrics of exclusion, exploitation, and suffering.” — Stan Chu Ilo These are the architects and custodians of structures of sin, who stitch together systems that bind, entrap, and hold a majority of God’s people in conditions of quiet bondage. Leo does not allow these structures to remain faceless or abstract; he exposes the patterns, unmasks the agents, and calls them to account, even as he summons the whole human community to the harder work of unweaving these fabrics of injustice and reweaving the social order according to the demands of justice, truth, and the dignity of all. Leo’s denunciation of leaders who invoke God in the service of domination is deeply Augustinian. It recalls Augustine’s critique of the libido dominandi as the root of political disorder and the great threat to the tranquility of order. Yet Leo is not naïve about the nature of political life. Like Augustine’s vision of the two cities interwoven in history, his approach acknowledges the persistence of conflict between competing values and visions of the good. “In this sense, his political theology resonates with what contemporary theory describes as an agonistic understanding of democracy: the recognition that conflict is enduring. However, Leo refuses to absolutize conflict. His insistence on dialogue is a call to transform antagonism into a space where differences can be expressed, contested, and discerned within an ethical horizon ordered to the common good, to the love of God and others, to the dignity of the human person, and to the flourishing of all.” — Stan Chu Ilo What is this prophetic political theology and how did Pope Leo capture it so far in his messages in Algeria and Cameroon? I will address this question in the second part of this essay.